Re my previous post:

[camwyn]

Mr. Ollivander potentially an Oan. Also Flitwick. That or the Oans are responsible for running Gringotts.

Houses are going to have to be a bit different 'cos otherwise EVERY SINGLE FRIGGEN GREEN LANTERN is in Gryffindor. Possibly the Houses instead represent mega-sectors.

"You told me my father died in an experimental plane crash!"

Kilowog makes a lovely substitute for Hagrid. Just as Sinestro does for Lord Voldemort.

Pretty sure the first book is in fact Harry Jordan and the Philosopher's Battery.

Dunno what to do about Carol Ferris. Considering tapping Thomas Kalmuka for the Ron Weasley slot despite Kalmuka not actually being a Lantern. John Stewart fairly easy to see as a pupil; Kyle Raynor takes the Colin Creevey slot; Guy Gardner, well, possibly Ernie Macmillan as he's a bit on the annoying side? Dunno.

Comments

[the-comish.livejournal.com]

May I suggest Alan Scott as Dumbledore?

[pandoras-closet.livejournal.com]

Lemme think on this and get back to you.

I will say this. Dumbledore, as the mentor, must be Oan. If not Oan, then another of the offshoots. Remember, the race which spawned the gaurdians branched off in dozens of directions eons ago.

If you really want to get fancy, recall that the Gaurdians have mates. I forget their names, but they're all women. Who says Ganthetadore(?) has to be male?

[camwyn]

Zamarrons, and they all have magic sapphires, if I remember right. McGonagall works pretty well for one of those.

I do fancy the Alan Scott idea, though. Given that Scott's lantern powers had something to do with a magic meteorite if I recall aright.

[camwyn]

Oooh! Now there's an idea. I like the sound of that.

'course that makes Jade one of the biggest Mary Sue ideas around- the Daughter or Granddaughter of Dumbledore- but enh, I'll live.

[skalja.livejournal.com]

*cries with laughter*

[camwyn]

DAMMIT I HAD A BRAIN WHEN I LEFT THE HOUSE THIS MORNING.

HOnestly, Harry Potter is to all other fandoms what attractive human women are to all varieties of space alien in bad SF: the stock to which it is almost universally possible to breed, so long as one takes a few token measures to ensure a good fit.

[prodigal.livejournal.com]

You recall correctly, sir.

As for Gardner, is theer anybody who starts out sympathetic in the beginning of the books, but becomes a total asstard by the final one . . . hey, I know.

Guy Gardner as Cornelius Fudge.

[camwyn]

I dunno, that's stretching things a little bit in terms of approximate level of responsibility.

He'd make a damn fine Percy, though.

[prodigal.livejournal.com]

I'm working from an admittedly limited direct knowledge of the books, only having read OOtP (and that, more than a year ago,) but why not have Carol Ferris take the place of one of the girls who broke the oath not to tell anybody about Dumbledore's Army?

Arisia would have to be either Cho Chang or Ginny Weasley - she started out a child whose hero worship of Hal caused her to have her ring artificially age her to adulthood, but eventually came to realise that her feelings for him were just the infatuation of a girl for an older man.

And Katma Tui would make an interesting Hermione-analogue, what with her being the one chosen to take Sinestro's place in the Corps when he was cast down.

[prodigal.livejournal.com]

Fudge is the only one I know made an analogous descent from decent human being to "I wouldn't piss on him if he were on fire" territory. Gardner was a great character at first, but sometime around the Crisis, he turned into an utter shit.

[skalja.livejournal.com]

Absolutely! I've discussed this before with other friends, actually, when I was more heavily involved in Potter fandom:

- Horatio Hornblower is a wizard who escaped into Muggle society, and that's why his name is so weird;
- after graduation, HP wanders over to NYC and chats with Spider-man mid-air, and also gets trained by Dr. Strange;
- etc.

that is lovely

[chaos-wrangler.livejournal.com]

*laughter* & had to read immediately (after laughter was under control) to G.

[camwyn]

I know I can't crossbreed it to Ayn Rand's fictional universes. The fundamental postulates are too different. Otherwise, though, not so hard. Although I've never really tried to do a cross between HP and LOTR; too many horrible fics have resulted from that. I'm allergic now.

[filkerdave.livejournal.com]

Through brightest day, in blackest night
No Death Eater shall escape my sight
Let those who worship Voldemort's might
Beware my wand and Gryffindor's light!

[midnightlurker.livejournal.com]

Zamarons with one R, to be pedantic.

The meteorite was the Starheart, created by the Oans--their powers were once both psionic and mystic in nature, but they decided long ago to purge themselves of the chaos inherent in the magic side, and lumped it all into a chunk of green metal and tried to lock it away in the core of a sun. It got out, fell in ancient China, and prophecied that it would burn three times--once to bring death, once to bring life, once to bring power. Scott got the last bit; his lantern and ring are made of that meteor.

Ayn Rand?

[jessara40k.livejournal.com]

Who is Ayn Rand and which fictional universes did she come up with?

[lots42.livejournal.com]

Carol Ferris should be run over by a truck wiped out of continuity in every bit of canon and fandom ever.

[dragonwhishes.livejournal.com]

And I thought I had too many plot bunnies to be healthy...

Re: Ayn Rand?

[camwyn]

She's basically the spiritual godmother of all Libertarians and their ilk everywhere. Founded the Objectivist school of philosophy. Very much into capitalism, free market foo, etc. Wrote Atlas Shrugged, The Fountainhead, Anthem, things like that. However, since her fiction is primarily used to put forward her philosophy, one of the absolute core tenets of her universe is that the supernatural, mystic, divine, and anything else related does not exist. Unless something can be objectively and logically proven to truly exist, it isn't worth considering.

This may be a significant chunk of why she died of lung cancer, because she spent a lot of her life arguing that the studies linking cigarettes to lung cancer were faulty, slanted against the companies that made tobacco, and otherwise Not Real Proof.

[isustrikanda.livejournal.com]

Harry Potter is...the stock to which it is almost universally possible to breed, so long as one takes a few token measures to ensure a good fit.

Shared this whole thing with my honey (after wiping Little Debbie off my comp. screen).
He says: What's next?? Harry Potter and the Dendarii Mercenaries? Harry Potter and the Freman Rebels? Harry Potter on the Streets of Ankh-Morpork? Harry Potter vs. Terminator?

Harry Potter and the Dalek Invasion of Time?
"Expelliarmus!" Harry yelled. The Dalek was thrown backward but another one moved forward to take its place.
"Exterminate!" the monster said in its clockwork voice.
Hermione grabbed Harry and pulled him away, "Harry, come on! We can't possibly fight them all! We have to find Professor Doctor quickly!"

Me: you gotta admit, he'd make a hell of a Dark Arts teacher....

my honey: actually that's EXACTLY what I was thinking
....oh lord . . .Camwyn is right. . . .
excuse me for a minute . .. I need to go find a spork to gouge my brains out with.

[aethereal-girl.livejournal.com]

Oh dear. That should not be allowed, at all.

[isustrikanda.livejournal.com]

{grins} no... no, it shouldn't. but it's still *funny*.

the conversation went on, recorded here: http://www.livejournal.com/users/isustrikanda/55648.html#cutid1

Re: Ayn Rand?

[midnightlurker.livejournal.com]

When it comes to Libertarian fiction I prefer L. Neil Smith. Now, crossing HP and the Probability Broach series... that might be amusing...

[derien.livejournal.com]

I'm going to have to steal that quote. I just had to quote it to someone.